Rodgers and Hart: Ten Enduring Songs

Last week, we celebrated the 117th anniversary of the birth of Richard Rodgers with one of the composer’s piano roll recordings. We discussed the simple, effortless perfection of Rodgers’ melodies and the way his style changed from his work with lyricist Lorenz Hart in the 1920s and 30s to his partnership with Oscar Hammerstein II in the 1940s and 50s. The latter collaboration transformed the Broadway musical from a loose collection of catchy songs into an integrated drama in which the music was essential in furthering the plot and character development.

Today, let’s listen to ten incredible songs written by Rodgers and Hart. Each of these songs has a beautiful, seemingly inevitable melodic structure. Underneath the cleverness and virtuosity of Lorenz Hart’s lyrics there is occasionally a sense of sadness and longing.

“Where or When”

The ballad “Where or When” came early in the first scene of the 1937 musical comedy, Babes in Arms. The lyrics are a wistful reflection on the phenomenon of déjà vu. The melody begins as a simple, ascending three-note scale. Listen to the way it establishes these three notes as a “frame” and then reaches one note higher, giving us a sense of striving and wistful, dreamy transcendence.

Here is a 1951 studio recording featuring Mary Martin:

“My Funny Valentine”

Babes in Arms also included the haunting and melancholy “My Funny Valentine.” The lyrics offer an example of the loneliness and isolation that often surfaces in Hart’s lyrics. Harmonically, this song is extraordinary. It begins in minor with a descending chromatic bass line. Notice the sense of darkness implied by the dissonance on the first “valentine” (0:44). The movement to the relative major in the bridge section only makes the return to minor and the song’s final resolution more affecting.

Here is Mary Martin:

“The Lady Is a Tramp”

Another hit song from Babes in Arms is “The Lady is a Tramp,” a swinging list song which takes sardonic aim at the social pretensions of New York high society. Rodgers’ melody includes a distinctive flatted seventh in the second bar. The song has been recorded by everyone from Frank Sinatra and Ella Fitzgerald to Lady Gaga.

Here, again, is Mary Martin:

“I Could Write a Book”

This ballad came early in the first act of the 1940 musical Pal Joey, one of Rodgers and Hart’s final shows. In the original production it was introduced by Gene Kelly and Leila Ernst. The song represents the manipulative Joey’s pickup line as he attempts to ingratiate himself to Linda. The enticing, almost hypnotic simplicity of the melody keeps “I Could Write a Book”on the edge between sincerity and deception.

This 1950 recording features Harold Lang and Beverly Fite:

“Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered”

Later in the first act of Pal Joey, Vera describes her weakness for Joey in “Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered.” In Rodgers’ melody, listen to the way the half step interval is repeated with almost obsessive persistence. We hear it five times (each time on the word “again”), and then the sixth time (on the word “bewitched”) the melody finally seems to break free.

Vivienne Segal introduced the song in the original Broadway production. Here is her 1950 recording:

“I Didn’t Know What Time It Was”

This dreamy melody came in the second act of the 1939 musical comedy, Too Many Girls. Listen closely to all of the harmonic surprises this song has in store. It begins where we least expect, as if floating in midair. Minor drifts into major, and then back. We never know exactly what is around the next corner. All of this sophistication has inspired jazz versions like this one by Charlie Parker.

Here is a 1996 recording featuring Dawn Upshaw:

“Thou Swell”

In “Thou Swell,” 1920s slang meets old English. The up-tempo duet was written for the 1927 musical, A Connecticut Yankee, based on Mark Twain’s novel, A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court. This melody introduces a short, searching motif centering around a descending major second and then restates it, climbing exuberantly in register. To hear it in all of its swinging, 1920s glory, listen to this 1927 Franklyn Baur recording.

Here is Dawn Upshaw and David Garrison:

“Isn’t It Romantic?”

In his book, American Popular Song: The Great Innovators 1900–1950Alec Wilder calls this “a perfect song.” “Isn’t It Romantic?” was introduced by Maurice Chevalier and Jeanette MacDonald in the 1932 Paramount film, Love Me Tonight. In one scene of the film, it becomes an “infectious” melody, passed from one character to another. The entire melody develops out of an opening five-note motif that seems to be searching for a way forward. Listen to the neat way the melody concludes by landing on these same five notes. Also, listen for the “wrong” note at the end of the bridge which provides the perfect half step pick up to lead into a restatement of the A section.

Here is Jeanette MacDonald:

“Blue Moon” (originally “The Bad in Every Man”)

In 1930 as the Great Depression deepened, Rodgers and Hart relocated to Hollywood. While investment in the film industry was growing by leaps and bounds and the songs placed in films instantly attracted a wider audience than on Broadway, the team was unhappy working in Hollywood. In his biography of Richard Rodgers, William G. Hyland explains,

The major studios were interested in having hit songs in their productions, but the musical knowledge of the producers and many of the directors was limited. The studios therefore put together rudimentary staffs of resident songwriters, musical arrangers, and conductors. The cumbersome system did not necessarily stimulate creativity, but eventually it produced a body of good music. Nevertheless, even the established composers lost control over whether and how their songs would be used. The final film might contain only snatches of a song.

The famous hit, Blue Moon, grew out of this process. In 1934, Rodgers and Hart found themselves churning out mediocre songs for a “screwball comedy to end all screwball comedies” called Hollywood Party. (The film starred Laurel and Hardy, The Three Stooges, Jimmy Durante, Lupe Vélez and Mickey Mouse). One gem emerged from the score—a song written for Jean Harlow called “Prayer” (“Oh Lord, make me a movie star”) which was set to the melody we now know as Blue Moon. After Prayer” was cut from the film, Hart wrote new lyrics and the song, now known as “It’s Just That Kind of Play,” was retooled for the 1934 gangster film, Manhattan Melodrama. In this form, the song was also cut. Then, the studio asked for a nightclub number. Hart wrote a third lyric and the result was “The Bad in Every Man”:

Following the film’s release, the brief melody drew the ear of Jack Robbins, the head of the studio’s publishing company. He persuaded a now reluctant Lorenz Hart to write yet another set of lyrics which would ensure the song’s wider commercial success. Blue Moon, heard here in its final form, may be the first song to use the I–vi–IV–V chord progression which became popular in the 1950s.

“My Heart Stood Still”

The effortless inevitability of Rodgers’ melodies is on full display in “My Heart Stood Still.” The song was originally written for the 1927 Charles Cochran revue One Dam Thing after Another. It found new life the same year in A Connecticut Yankee. Here is Jeanette MacDonald’s 1938 recording.

We’ll conclude where we began a week ago—with Richard Rodgers’ own piano roll recording:


  • The Broadway Cast Collection, Vol. 1: “Where or When,” “My Funny Valentine,” “The Lady is a Tramp,”Mary Martin Amazon
  • Pal Joey (1950 Studio Cast): “I Could Write a Book,” “Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered.”Amazon
  • Dawn Upshaw Sings Rodgers and Hart: “I Didn’t Know What Time it Was,” “Thou Swell” Amazon
  • Rodgers and Hammerstein Write the Songs: “Isn’t it Romantic?” “Blue Moon” Amazon
  • Richard Rodgers: Command Performance: “My Heart Stood Still” Amazon

About Timothy Judd

A native of Upstate New York, Timothy Judd has been a member of the Richmond Symphony violin section since 2001. He is a graduate of the Eastman School of Music where he earned the degrees Bachelor of Music and Master of Music, studying with world renowned Ukrainian-American violinist Oleh Krysa.

The son of public school music educators, Timothy Judd began violin lessons at the age of four through Eastman’s Community Education Division. He was a student of Anastasia Jempelis, one of the earliest champions of the Suzuki method in the United States.

A passionate teacher, Mr. Judd has maintained a private violin studio in the Richmond area since 2002 and has been active coaching chamber music and numerous youth orchestra sectionals.

In his free time, Timothy Judd enjoys working out with Richmond’s popular SEAL Team Physical Training program.

5 thoughts on “Rodgers and Hart: Ten Enduring Songs”

  1. This was certainly a trip down memory lane. All the songs you presented are well-known and are still played and sung occasionally in various venues. I have especially fond memories of “Where or When” as I taught my older brother, who had 2 left feet, to dance to this number, one of the very few records that we had. Those were the days….

  2. A grand selection of wonderful songs. Funny how some of the songs have outlived the films that introduced them. They are all still fresh. My favorite cover of Where or When is Barbra Streisand’s from her album Color Me Barbra.

  3. Of course Manhattan Melodrama was the film John Dillinger was watching at The Biograph Cinema, on Lincoln Avenue in Chicago – sat there withere with the Lady in Red, who betrayed him. Apparently “What a good film” were his last words – because on walking out of the cinema he was gunned down by the FBI.


Leave a Comment